I guess it depends on what you need out of your tire. I don't take my truck off the hard surface. I live in northwestern Pa and we can have some pretty bad winters. I live on a secondary road. I went with the AT2's to give me good bite but not a lot of road noise. This is the first time running them for me so I hope I made the right choice. The guys at Bully's Performance also told me that was the right choice for me too. Try them they may be able to help you out. Tell them what your plans are for your truck and see what they have too say.