Yea, it looks good in the pic but in person you can definitely see the bulb because the whole light is not diffused only the front part. I contacted recon and sent them pictures of the rubber gasket I came up with and the guy, mike, said he would send it on to the design team. I'm planning to replace them with another set using my rubber gasket instead of the foam one.
I installed them myself, got the measurements off my buddy's 2012 3500. I thought I was gonna pass out when I drilled the first hole!!
Here's some pics of the gasket: