Not exactly,,,
On 4th Gens,You'll notice the e-fan comes on everytime you turn your A/C on. Hot, cold, whatever,,,, keeps air moving over the condenser and the A/C works better.
As it does not turn off exactly at the moment the A/C is switched off, I cannot confirm or deny that the E-fan may also be temp regulated,,, Again,,:4-dontknow:
In the summer when its hot, my A/C and my e-fan run constantly. I drive pretty conservatively, Houston is pretty level, and I don't tow or haul,,,
In my case, even in stop and go traffic, the E-fan seems to move enough air to keep from running hot or from having the thermal clutch engage.
(FWIW, the 3.7's have electric only cooling, and their fans look virtually identical to the ones the 4.7 / 5.7 have strapped to the rad in front of the thermal clutch)
Now, in stop and go traffic,,, If I were to tow, drive aggressively, run up steep grades, etc,,, the E-fan may not be enough,,, and the clutch fan is there to assist. (Still don't know if the E-fan is linked to temp for sure)
The clutch fan itself, if memory serves me, is only a 'rather modest' nylon/plastic 5 blade,,, not a real 'air mover' when compared to the 9 blade "20 lb" OEM metal fan I had back on my 455 Firebird,,,
So,,, How much parasitic loss does one get from a 'typically disengaged' lightweight 5 blade fan? :4-dontknow:
Even when disengaged, it does pull a little air at the stoplights, which isn't a bad thing,,,
If one wants to go full electric, I understand, but in my situation, with the cost of parts and my time to install, I just am not convinced that the difference in fuel economy would ever justify the expense.
I don't race, so a quicker rev'ing engine (less mass to spool up) wouldn't matter...
As always, Your mileage may vary!