Come on guys. No need to get off the topic and start arguing about good vs bad driver and all season vs winter tires.
Let's face it. Tires don't make anyone a better driver, but proper tires will improve the handling of your vehicle. Maybe not a lot, but it for sure helps. Whether you need winter tires is, like I said, a personal preference. It all comes down to one question, "Do you feel safe driving your vehicle in the winter without winter tires?"
I had a Toyota Echo for 5 years, the lightest car you can imagine, with no winter tires and I was ok with that. Why? Because I took bus to school everyday and I was only using my car to get groceries on weekends. At that time, I lived downtown and the roads were always plowed. Did I feel safe? Yes.
I also had a 2wd Chevy pickup for 6 years. I put all WEATHER tires (goodyear territory) on it. (All weather tires do have the snow peak logo). I sometimes get stuck on bad weather, but it's not too bad. Did I feel safe? Most of time, but not on very stormy days.
Now I am a proud owner of a 4X4 Ram. Why the hell am I getting winter tires then I didn't have them before. Well, I want MAX safety. That's what I want, and that's why I am paying extra to get winter tires.
Do whatever you want, all seasons or winters, Just ask yourself this question "Do you feel safe without winter tires?"